Call in / Take Out

Craving our mouth-watering New York-style pizza?
Call us now to place your takeout order – we’re just one call away from satisfying your pizza cravings!

Dine In

Can’t resist the aroma of freshly-baked pizza? Swing by for a dine-in experience like no other and choose your favorites from our tempting menu – your taste buds will thank you!

Order Online

Great news for pizza lovers – you’ll soon be able to order your favorite Elidio’s Pizza slices right from the comfort of your home! Keep an eye out for our new online ordering!

Fresh Toppings, Perfect Pizza: Experience the Elidio’s Difference!

Experience a burst of freshness with every bite! At Elidio’s Pizza, our toppings are hand-picked for their quality and freshness, ensuring your pizza is nothing short of perfection.

Download Clearwater Menu

Download Knoxville Menu

A family favorite for over 40 years!

Several Names, Same Pizza?

From our inception as Cosimo’s Pizza in the ’80s, through the ’90s as Prima Pizza, to our latest incarnation as Elidio’s Pizza, our name may have evolved, but our signature New York-style pizza, steeped in quality and taste, remains unwavering.

1984 – COSMOS PIZZA

From our early days at East Town Mall, Cosmo’s Pizza proudly served high-quality New York style pizza.

1990’s – PRIMA PIZZA

Nestled at the heart of the Cumberland Strip, we fed students, staff, fans, and Peyton Manning for almost a decade. Go Vols!

2000’s – ELIDIO’S PIZZA

Now nestled at the junction of Calahan Rd and Central Ave, our thriving Elidio’s Pizza location has sparked a city-wide expansion, bringing our cherished New York-style pizza to more neighborhoods.

2025 – ELIDIO’S PIZZA

Now serving sunshine and slices on Missouri Avenue in Clearwater, Florida, Elidio’s Pizza is bringing our famous New York-style flavor to the Gulf Coast. This new location marks an exciting chapter in our journey—sharing the same beloved taste, warmth, and community spirit that made Elidio’s a Knoxville favorite, now baked fresh daily in Clearwater!